Where to find Malcolm Coles, reviews, and tips on how to do things I couldn’t do.

malcolm coles


The BBC and Guardian: more reasons I hate mobile sites 1

Posted on May 10, 2010 by Malcolm Coles

Mobile versions of websites - what a train crash they often are. As I write this, at 10.30pm on Monday night, neither the BBC nor Guardian mobile websites are mentioning that Gordon Brown has promised to resign ... a story that their web news pages are unsurprising leading with - and have been doing so for several hours.

I'm sure it's hard to implement a mobile version of a website - with ITV's mobile site particularly demonstrating why they're often rubbish.

But I expected rather more of the BBC and the Guardian. In fact, if you've been using their mobile sites for the last few days, you'd have been under the impression that there has been little news about the election to report...

The Guardian

Here's the Guardian's mobile version tonight - no mention of Gordon Brown quitting.

Guardian: no sign of resigning PMs

Guardian: no sign of resigning PMs

And here's its web version - leading with the news.

Guardian web: Brown's resigned

Guardian web: Brown's resigned

The BBC

Here's the BBC mobile site on Sunday morning - literally no mention of the election whatsoever. It's been like this for days...

BBC mobile: any election news?

BBC mobile: any election news?

And here's the web version of its news pages at the same time. Oh, there's an election.

BBC web: there's an election!

BBC web: there's an election!

And tonight, again, there is no mention of the election and no mention of Brown's resignation on the mobile version of the BBC's news pages:

Brown has resigned, I'm sure ...

Brown has resigned, I'm sure ...

Back to the drawing board, please.

You might also like
  1. Guardian makes its comments accessible, SEO friendly and mobile friendly all in one go!
  2. Tanya Gold in the Guardian: advert #fail
  3. The Guardian and accessibility
  4. 90 minutes later, some newspaper sites haven't published the football score
  5. Google street view: which news sites linked?,

You should follow me on Twitter.

One Response to “The BBC and Guardian: more reasons I hate mobile sites”

  1. JC says:

    I'm no expert, but could this be to do with the mobile operators caching sites? I would have thought the content of these big sites are just styled differently for certain browsers rather than seperate content systems. But like I say, i'm no expert.

Leave a Reply

All comments are moderated. Comments that include URLs and which just say 'Nice post' or similar won't be published, but thanks for the sentiment.

Find more posts like this



↑ Top