Comic relief: which news sites gave a proper link, and which didn’t?
News websites aren't always great at linking out. But they might put a bit of effort into it for good causes. So how well did news sites do at linking to rednoseday.com, the site for the high-profile fundraising day for Comic Relief, when they covered it?
In particular, how many of them mentioned the website and DID make it a hyperlink? And how many DIDN'T make it a hyperlink?
To find out, I did a search on 'rednoseday.com' at each site and checked the latest story on or before Red Nose Day (13th March). If no results were found, I did a search on comicrelief.com instead. (The FT largely ignored the event, so isn't shown. And the BBC organises it, so it's not shown).
Sites that managed a link: Telegraph, Guardian, Mail, Sun, Five, ITV.
Sites that didn't: Times, Independent, Express, Mirror, Channel 4.
Times Online: URLs were not made links
Page checked. "For more information on Comic Relief and how to donate money go to www.rednoseday.com. For more information on Jeccdo, go to www.smcfethiopia.org". Not a link.
Telegraph: Proper link
Guardian: Proper link
(Although I had to check it wasn't doing the Guardian's usual trick of linking brand names and other keywords to one of its own pages ...)
Independent: Not a link
Page checked. "www.comicrelief.com". Not a link.
Mail: Proper link
Didn't mention the websites in its coverage. Perhaps because of the comments on this page, which probably deserve a post of their own.
The Sun: Proper link
Mirror: Not a link
Page checked. "(Barry) Islands In The Stream is released tomorrow and available from www.rednoseday.com." Not a link.
Channel 4: Not a link
Page checked. "To sponsor the team visit http://www.rednoseday.com/sponsortheteam." Not a link.
Five: Proper link
ITV: Proper link
So, some news sites can provide links (now try to do it more often ...). While others can't easily or won't link out, even for charity. Try harder.
You might also like
- Google street view: which news sites linked?,
- Sites that drive the most USA traffic to UK newspaper sites
- 90 minutes later, some newspaper sites haven’t published the football score
- How sticky are visitors to UK newspaper sites?
- Nofollow and internal redirects: sites that accept links – but don’t link out fairly