Internet
How to
Newspapers
Twitter
SEO advice
Categories: Bad reviews, Internet. Tags:

Worst UK Serps yet?

January 5, 2010 9 Comments

If buying a used car, I wonder what checks you should do on the documentation? Don't bother asking Google. My search for used car document check threw up sites, in order, on the first page from:

  1. UK
  2. India
  3. USA
  4. Ireland
  5. USA
  6. India
  7. USA
  8. Brazil
  9. UK

How is this possibly useful? All Indian, or all Brazilian or all American, I could understand. But advice from a mixture of countries on something as local as vehicle documentation? It's like the league of nations. A new low in the broken UK search results ...

You might also like
  1. Google acts to improve UK search results
  2. Login designs: the 9 worst ones and where to find good examples
  3. ITV: Please sort out your Champions League site
  4. The unbearable crapness of Google Trends
  5. SEO revenge: analytics style

Share this post

Follow me on Facebook or Twitter

9 Comments »

  • Kev Strong says:

    The UK Serps never cease to amaze me. Surely they should know after all this time that when you search for something as specific as "used car document check" that you are looking for results in your country.

    Thankfully, appending UK to the end of that query clears it up but how many people would search like that?

    Perhaps they are trying to force a change in search methods on its users to solve the problem as there are more and more instances of this solution having to be done to clean up the SERPs.

  • Mike says:

    How is that broken? You got results from the WORLD WIDE web. If you clicked "pages from the UK" then all the results are from the UK. Simples.

  • Richard Vaughan says:

    Mike: But the search was done in google.co.uk. The geo location of the search is assumed isn't it?

  • Mike: what Richard said. Who, anywhere in the world, would want information on vehicle documentation from a range of countries?

    Google should either stick to serving results from the country that's most appropriate for the search term (EG the country where it is most used as a search term) OR work out where I am and serve up local results.

    Serving up a hodge podge of results from around the world is of no use to anyone - it guarantees a second search will have to be done. The two other options I just gave would at least satisfy some people.

  • Anthony says:

    I bet it makes people click on the Sponsored listings though, don't you? :)

  • [...] one Google. More crap UK serps, although no doubt a boon to Manchester SEO [...]

  • Adam says:

    Sorry, I'm with Mike on this one. You want UK results - select the 'pages from the UK' option - that's what it's there for.

    How is Google meant to know that you don't want to compare 'used car document checks' around the world? Or do you think you should go to the local version of Google every time you want to search for something. So, going to China on holiday and want to look for a hotel - go to Google.cn - hmmm, except that's in Chinese!

    Surely the simple answer is to set the UK option as your default - then you'll get UK biased results - otherwise, why bother having that option at all?

  • [...] turning up for searches that were clearly looking for local information - in this blog post and this one. These issues followed earlier problems with US maps showing up for UK sites (see here and [...]

  • Marc Burns says:

    Hi,

    Interesting post. Personally I think local searching is going too far. I don't ALWAYS want search results based my locality.

    I don't even like the way UK sites are given priority when doing a worldwide search just because I happen to be in the UK!

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.